Dark
Light
Against a pink background, a graphic of Miley Cyrus swings on a wrecking ball from her iconic music video while Beyonce sings into a microphone in a black leotard.

Then vs. Now: Have 2014 Artists Withstood the Test of Time?

Exploring the longevity of artists and their albums from 2014 to 2024.
December 27, 2023
14 mins read

A decade has passed since the world echoed with the harmonies of melodies that defined an era. As we stand on the cusp of 2024, it’s hard to remember what those times were like; here to remind you, we will take a trip through time, a nostalgic voyage to the year 2014. The songs that graced our playlists, shaped our memories and became the soundtrack to countless moments are now reaching a significant milestone—turning ten. 2014 was a remarkable year for music, and as we celebrate the tenth anniversary of songs that shaped a generation, it’s an opportune moment to reflect on their impact and the artists who crafted them. The melodies, lyrics and emotions encapsulated in the songs of 2014 have not merely aged; they have matured like fine wine, gaining complexity and depth with each passing year. These tracks serve as more than mere relics of the past; they are living, breathing entities that continue to resonate with new audiences, forging connections across time and generations.

Charli XCX, “Sucker

In 2014, Charli XCX was already making waves with her infectious pop anthems, contributing significantly to the vibrant music landscape of the time. Known for her bold, rebellious style, she had just released her breakthrough album “Sucker,” featuring hits like “Boom Clap” and “Break the Rules.” She broke through on the big screen by having her music in the biggest movie of the year “The Fault in Our Stars”. Only at the ripe age of 21 was Charli becoming one of my favorites along with every other Tumblr user at the time. These tracks showcased her ability to blend catchy hooks with a punk-rock edge, establishing the early stages of her career in the pop scene.

Fast forward to 2024, and Charli XCX has undergone a remarkable evolution in her sound and artistic identity. In the intervening years, she has become a trailblazer in pop music’s experimental and futuristic realms. Albums like “Charli” (2019) and “How I’m Feeling Now” (2020) exhibit a departure from conventional pop structures, embracing a more avant-garde and electronic sound. Collaborations with cutting-edge producers and artists like Troye Sivan and Bebe Rexha have further solidified her status as a trendsetter, with songs like “Vroom Vroom” and “party4u” pushing the boundaries of pop norms.

Charli XCX’s album, particularly “Vroom Vroom” and “Pop 2,” showcases a dynamic collaboration with a roster of innovative producers who played a crucial role in shaping the unique sonic landscape of the project. At the forefront of this production powerhouse was the late Sophie, an electronic music pioneer whose influence has left an indelible mark on the music industry. Sophie, with her distinctive approach to production, brought a futuristic and avant-garde quality to Charli XCX’s sound. Her contributions to tracks like “Vroom Vroom” and “Paradise” added an experimental edge, characterized by glitchy beats, unconventional synth textures, and a fearless embrace of the unconventional. Sophie’s work with Charli XCX went beyond the conventional boundaries of pop music, pushing the envelope and challenging the expectations of what mainstream pop could sound like. Beyond Sophie, the album boasted collaborations with other notable producers such as A.G. Cook, who is also the founder of PC Music, and Dylan Brady. A.G. Cook’s influence on the album was substantial, bringing his knack for genre-blurring production and pushing the boundaries of pop music. Together, they crafted a sonic landscape that defied traditional pop norms, incorporating elements of electronic, hyper-pop, and experimental music.

Taylor Swift, “1989

At the top of the Instagram game, Taylor Swift had over 50 million followers who loved the inside peak of her life of girlfriends, cats and cakes. Swift was in the midst of a seismic shift in her musical identity. The album “1989” marked a departure from her country roots, embracing a synth-pop sound that would redefine her career. The lyrics of songs like “Shake It Off” and “Blank Space” were both introspective and self-aware, showcasing Swift’s adeptness at storytelling. Themes of love, heartbreak and self-discovery resonated with audiences, and the album solidified her status as a pop powerhouse. 

Continuing to explore pop music along with folk genres, Swift has broken multiple streaming records and dominated the concert scene with her Eras Tour. It was the years in between as well which proved that she was destined for greatness. The “Reputation” era, spanning 2017 to 2018, marked a pivotal moment in Taylor Swift’s career, characterized by a departure from her established image and the embrace of a darker, edgier persona, stepping away from her girl-next-door image. This era showcased Swift’s resilience in the face of public scrutiny and her ability to harness personal narratives into artistic expressions. She incorporated elements of sci-fi and cyberpunk aesthetics into her music videos and public appearances, offering a visual narrative that aligned with the album’s themes of reinvention and defiance. As the “Reputation” era unfolded, Taylor Swift not only successfully navigated the challenges of fame but also showcased her ability to command attention and redefine her narrative on her own terms. The era set the stage for subsequent shifts in her sound and image, proving that Taylor Swift’s career is a dynamic and ever-evolving journey through the complexities of artistry and self-discovery. 

As 2024 unfolds, Taylor Swift is continuing to embark on “The Eras Tour,” a monumental celebration of her diverse musical journey. Swift’s venture into indie pop not only expanded her musical repertoire but also demonstrated her commitment to artistic freedom. Embracing a more hands-on approach in production and songwriting, she solidified her status as a musical auteur. The success of these ventures not only endeared her to longtime fans but also garnered new admiration for her ability to break free from the constraints of mainstream pop.

In 2024, Taylor Swift stands as a paragon of reinvention, a testament to the enduring power of artistic exploration. Her journey from country princess to indie-pop maven reflects not just a change in musical style but a maturation of an artist who continuously seeks new avenues for self-expression and connection with her audience. Now as we wait for “Reputation” (Taylor’s Version), it is nice to take a trip down memory lane to remind us that “there will be no explanation, there will just be reputation.”

Paramore, “Paramore

In similar pop realms, one of my all-time favorite bands Paramore released some of their best work in that year. Paramore was experiencing a renaissance with their self-titled album released in 2013. The lyrics of tracks like “Ain’t It Fun” and “Still Into You” resonated with themes of resilience, growth and the challenges of navigating adulthood. Hayley Williams’ poignant lyricism and the band’s dynamic sound established the album as a cornerstone in Paramore’s discography.

In the past ten years, Paramore’s lyrical landscape has evolved alongside their musical experimentation. With the release of “After Laughter” in 2017, the band explored a more synth-pop sound, accompanied by introspective lyrics that delved into themes of mental health and self-discovery. Songs like “Hard Times” and “This is Why” showcased a more vulnerable and mature Paramore, revealing a depth in their lyricism that resonated with longtime fans and newcomers alike. 

Kendrick Lamar, “To Pimp a Butterfly

In 2014, Kendrick Lamar’s “I” was a departure from the gritty realism of his previous work, offering a more uplifting and self-affirming message. The track sampled the Isley Brothers’ “That Lady” and showcased Kendrick’s versatility as an artist. Following the success of “I,” Kendrick Lamar released “To Pimp a Butterfly” in 2015, a critically acclaimed album that delved into complex themes of race, identity and societal issues. The album won multiple Grammy Awards, solidifying Kendrick’s position as a thought-provoking lyricist and a powerful voice in hip-hop.

After “To Pimp a Butterfly,” Kendrick took a deliberate hiatus from solo releases, contributing to film soundtracks and collaborating with other artists. His silence built anticipation for his next move. By 2024, Kendrick Lamar had become a symbol of artistic integrity and innovation. Fans eagerly awaited his return, anticipating the depth and social commentary that had become synonymous with his name. Kendrick’s impact on hip-hop transcended music; he became a cultural icon known for pushing boundaries and challenging the status quo.

Nicki Minaj, “The Pinkprint

Nicki Minaj’s “Anaconda” in 2014 was a flamboyant and unabashed celebration of femininity and body positivity. Sampling Sir Mix-a-Lot’s “Baby Got Back,” the track became a chart-topping hit and a cultural touchstone. Nicki’s playful yet assertive lyrics and memorable visuals solidified her as a dominant force in the hip-hop landscape. Post-2014, Nicki Minaj continued to shape the trajectory of her career. She released albums like “The Pinkprint” (2014) and “Queen” (2018), showcasing her versatility as a rapper and singer. Nicki’s influence expanded into fashion, with her unique style and colorful personas leaving an indelible mark. Beyond her musical endeavors, Nicki became an entrepreneur, launching successful business ventures, and using her platform to advocate for issues, including women’s empowerment.

By 2024, Nicki Minaj’s impact was undeniable. Her legacy extended beyond music charts; she had become a symbol of empowerment and resilience in the face of industry challenges. Fans eagerly anticipated her future endeavors, acknowledging her pivotal role in breaking barriers for women in hip-hop and influencing the genre’s landscape. 


Although most songs that were on that radio can easily be erased from my mind, these previously stated songs are the ones that I like to remember. I can proudly say that the last time I willingly listened to the song “Happy” by Pharrell was in the year 2014. Or songs like “Wiggle,” with its cheeky lyrics and simplistic beat, entered the pop scene in 2014 as a dancefloor filler. Jason Derulo and Snoop Dogg collaborated on a track that, while momentarily popular, didn’t secure a lasting legacy. In the grand scheme of pop music history, “Wiggle” is a track that tends to get lost in the shuffle, a reminder that not every song is destined for eternal prominence.

As we reflect on the pop music landscape of 2014, it becomes evident that certain songs have stood the test of time, becoming anthems that continue to define the decade. The hits of that year serve as a musical time capsule, transporting us back to moments of joy, heartbreak and celebration. While some tracks have gracefully faded, others remain eternally embedded in our cultural consciousness, reminding us that the power of pop music lies in its ability to capture the spirit of an era and carry it forward through the sands of time.

Emma Troise, Manhattan College

Writer Profile

Emma Troise

Manhattan College
English

"My name is Emma Troise and I am receiving my degree at Manhattan College in English Literature. I am twenty years old living in New York City, and in my junior year of college.I am an inspiring writer and editor, and can not wait to learn!"

Don't Miss