Dark
Light
Illustration by Emily Daugherty, Ohio State University

The Best Hidden Gems Christmas Albums

These albums don’t always get the attention they deserve, but they hold the same magic that can make your holiday season special.

While we all love the familiar tunes in Mariah Carey’s “Merry Christmas” and Michael Bublé’s “Christmas,” there is something exciting about exploring lesser-known Christmas albums. These hidden gems offer unique interpretations of holiday classics that capture the spirit of the season in a different way. To expand our Christmas playlist beyond the mainstream hits, we can discover new artists, genres, and arrangements that add a new touch of magic to our holiday celebrations. Let’s uncover the hidden holiday treasures that deserve a spot in our Christmas playlists. 

CHRISTMAS EP” BY PHOEBE BRIDGERS

Phoebe Bridgers’ Christmas songs showcase her unique and hauntingly beautiful style. With her signature soft vocals and melancholic melodies, she brings a refreshing twist to classic holiday tunes. Bridgers’ rendition of “Christmas Song” is particularly captivating, as she infuses the songs with a bittersweet longing that captures the complex emotions often felt during the holiday season. 

Another standout is her cover of “If We Make It Through December“, where she creates a delicate and ethereal atmosphere that is both soothing and haunting. Her stripped-down vocals allow the lyrics to shine, creating a sense of intimacy and warmth. Bridgers’ Christmas EP captivates listeners with its raw and vulnerable energy making this album a  must-listen for anyone looking for a more contemplative approach to the holiday season.

CHRISTMAS” BY LOW

“Christmas” by Low is a beautiful album that captures the essence of the holiday season. The minimalistic approach to the music creates a serene and peaceful atmosphere, making it perfect for cozying up by the fireplace on a chilly winter night. The soft vocals and delicate instrumentation create a sense of intimacy that draws the listener in and evokes nostalgia. These tracks are noteworthy featuring classic holiday tunes and original compositions that are equally captivating. These songs sound nothing like Christmas music is expected to sound. If listeners didn’t pay attention to the lyrics, they would think these are just some alternative songs. Overall, “Christmas” by Low is a masterful work that brings warmth and joy to the holiday season.

A DIFFERENT CHRISTMAS” BY BRYSON TILLER

Bryson Tiller’s album, “A Different Christmas,” offers a unique spin on holiday music. With a blend of R&B and soul, Tiller brings a modern twist to traditional Christmas songs. The album features smooth and soulful vocals, like those heard in his rendition of “I’ll Be Home for Christmas,” which perfectly complement the festive atmosphere. The production is top-notch with catchy melodies and well-crafted arrangements. Tiller also includes a few original tracks, like “Lonely Christmas” with Justin Bieber and Poo Bear, that showcase his songwriting skills. Overall, “A Different Christmas” is an enjoyable and refreshing addition to the holiday music genre. It’s sure to please fans of Tiller’s discography  and those in search of something different for their holiday playlist.

A CHRISTMAS ALBUM” BY BRIGHT EYES

Bright Eyes’ “A Christmas Album” is a delightful departure from the typical holiday fare. The album strikes the perfect balance between tradition and innovation, offering a fresh take on familiar carols. Oberst’s heartfelt vocals, coupled with acoustic guitars and subtle instrumentation, create an intimate and warm atmosphere. The band holds the ability to bring melancholia to tracks like “Blue Christmas” that make their album uniquely resonant. In a genre often saturated with cheer, “A Christmas Album” stands out for its sincerity and thoughtful reinterpretations, making it a welcome addition to any holiday playlist.

TAYLOR SWIFT HOLIDAY COLLECTION” BY TAYLOR SWIFT

It might feel weird to see Taylor Swift on this list since she is one of the biggest pop stars in the world right now. Despite Swift’s status as a global pop sensation, the EP “Taylor Swift Holiday Collection” released in 2007,  remains relatively undiscovered by many. This EP showcases Swift’s signature heartfelt vocals and her youthful charm made into classic holiday tunes. One of the album’s strengths lies in its simplicity of stripped-down acoustic arrangements. Swift’s vocals take center stage creating a warm and inviting atmosphere for the holiday season. Swift’s Christmas collection is a must-listen for all the Swifties out there and a pleasant addition to any Christmas playlist.

NAVIDADES LUIS MIGUEL” BY LUIS MIGUEL

“Navidades Luis Miguel” is not just an album; it’s a Latin holiday symphony crafted with the timeless charm that defines Miguel’s music, which brings a touch of warmth to familiar Christmas tunes. From the moment the opening track begins, listeners are transported into a world where the magic of Christmas is intertwined with soulful sounds of Latin music. Miguel’s velvety voice lends a rich and emotional quality to each track, turning traditional carols into heartfelt serenades. “Navidades Luis Miguel” enchants listeners with its melodic sophistication, making it a perfect soundtrack for any holiday celebrations.


As the snow falls and the jingle of bells fills the air, consider taking a listen to these hidden gems. This holiday season, unwrap the gift of underrated Christmas albums and let their melodies add a touch of magic to your celebrations. May the tunes that have been hidden in the shadows find their way into your playlists, making this holiday season a special one filled with surprises, nostalgia, and the joy of discovering underrated albums that make Christmas truly special.

Karla D. Galvan, The University of Texas at San Antonio

Writer Profile

Karla Galvan

The University of Texas at San Antonio
Communication, Minor in Marketing

"I am a college student majoring in Communication with a passion for writing and an interest in anything pop culture, especially music and film!"

Don't Miss