Ian Linn, Oberlin College

While the show seeks to fight stereotypes by taking them to the extreme, it doesn’t go nearly far enough to make a meaningful statement.

L.R. Staples, Sarah Lawrence College

While the crime drama has paved the way in featuring plus-size female leads, does this representation trump other questionable casting choices?

Haven Worley, University of Rochester

‘F— Anyone Who’s Not A Sea Blob’ can come across as disjointed at points, but when it sticks to its central theme, it creates something gut-wrenching.